When it comes to iconic American chocolate, two confectionery giants stand above the rest — Hershey’s and Mars. These legendary brands have been satisfying sweet cravings for generations. But in the age of online shopping, only one can dominate the digital shelves. So, which one takes the crown on Amazon.com?
In this chocolate showdown, we’ll compare best-selling products, customer reviews, flavors, and popularity to determine the ultimate chocolate bar champion. Whether you’re team Reese’s or a die-hard Snickers fan, this is the chocolate face-off you didn’t know you needed!
🍫 Round 1: Product Variety – Who Offers More on Amazon?
Hershey’s Highlights
- HERSHEY’S KISSES Milk Chocolate Party Pack
- HERSHEY’S NUGGETS Assorted Chocolates
- REESE’S Peanut Butter Cups
- KIT KAT Crisp Wafers in Milk Chocolate
- HERSHEY’S Milk Chocolate Bars (36 ct)
➡ Great for: Variety lovers, holiday gifts, and peanut butter fans.
Image | Product | Rating | Price |
1
![]() |
HERSHEY’S KISSESMilk Chocolate Party Pack |
4.5
|
|
2
![]() |
HERSHEY’S NUGGETSAssorted Chocolates |
4.6
|
|
3
![]() |
REESE’SPeanut Butter Cups |
4.6
|
|
4
![]() |
KIT KATCrisp Wafers in Milk Chocolate |
4.7
|
|
5
![]() |
HERSHEY’S Milk ChocolateBars |
4.5
|
Mars Marvels
- SNICKERS, TWIX, and 3 MUSKETEERS Full-Size Bars
- MILKY WAY Chocolate Candy Bars
- M&M’S (Peanut, Milk Chocolate, Peanut Butter)
- Mars Variety Packs (150 Minis or Fun-Size Mixes)
➡ Great for: Caramel lovers, party packs, and snackable minis.
✅ Winner: Mars edges out with more variety in mix-and-match bundles and fun-size options.
⭐ Round 2: Amazon Best-Sellers & Ratings
On Amazon, consumer trust is everything — and reviews say a lot. Here’s how each brand stacks up:
Product | Avg. Rating | Total Reviews |
---|---|---|
HERSHEY’S KISSES Party Pack | 4.8 stars | 30,000+ |
REESE’S Peanut Butter Cups | 4.8 stars | 40,000+ |
KIT KAT Variety Pack | 4.7 stars | 25,000+ |
SNICKERS & TWIX Full-Size Pack | 4.7 stars | 28,000+ |
M&M’s Assorted Fun Size Pack | 4.8 stars | 35,000+ |
✅ Winner: Tie – Both brands maintain exceptional ratings and massive fan bases on Amazon.
💰 Round 3: Value for Money
- Hershey’s bulk bars and variety packs often offer more ounces per dollar, especially with classic items like Nuggets or Kisses.
- Mars, however, shines in multi-brand assortments (Snickers, Twix, Milky Way), offering more flavor diversity in one bag.
✅ Winner: Hershey’s for bulk value, Mars for flavor mix.
🎯 Round 4: Brand Power & Popularity
Both brands are American staples, but:
- Hershey’s is strongly associated with traditional chocolate and holidays.
- Mars wins among the younger crowd thanks to M&M’s marketing and its frequent collaboration with movies and pop culture.
✅ Winner: Mars, by a slight edge in mainstream and pop culture visibility.
🏆 And the Amazon Chocolate Champion Is…
It’s a close race, but based on product range, customer reviews, and innovative assortments, Mars takes the crown — by a chocolate-coated hair!
Still, Hershey’s holds strong as a trusted favorite, especially for purists and peanut butter lovers.
🎁 Top-Selling Picks You Can Order Now on Amazon
Here are some best-sellers from both brands you can grab today: